Permit parking for Dodsworth Avenue and Pottery Lane was dropped on 17 November after only 73 of 363 homes replied. The area is now off the council's waiting list.

Updated 18 November: the decision has been taken. The scheme will not go ahead and the area comes off the waiting list.

A residents’ parking scheme for Dodsworth Avenue and Pottery Lane has been scrapped, four years after people on Dodsworth Avenue petitioned for one. Too few households replied to the council’s survey to back it.

Councillor Kate Ravilious, the executive member for transport, took the decision at a session on Tuesday 17 November. She agreed that no further action be taken and that the area be removed from the council’s waiting list for residents’ parking (City of York Council decision sheet).

The decision sheet says the restrictions “will not be taken forward due to a very low rate of response from local residents and businesses”. It follows the officers’ recommendation in the council report.

What residents said

The council hand delivered questionnaires to 363 homes and businesses in June. The proposed zone, to be called R71, covered Dodsworth Avenue, Pottery Lane, Arran Place and Saxon Place in Heworth. Replies were due by 31 July.

Only 73 came back, a response rate of about 20%. Of those, 46 were in favour of permit parking and 27 against. The returns by street, from the council’s table of returns:

Street Homes asked Replies For Against
Dodsworth Avenue 134 40 32 8
Pottery Lane 168 29 12 17
Arran Place 44 3 1 2
Fossway 8 1 1 0
Saxon Place 9 0 0 0
Total 363 73 46 27

So Dodsworth Avenue was clearly for the idea among those who replied, and Pottery Lane, the biggest street in the zone, was narrowly against it.

The report accepts that support was stronger on Dodsworth Avenue, where 24% of households said yes. But officers will not recommend a scheme for that street alone. They say single street schemes “tend to result in high levels of displacement parking onto neighbouring streets”.

Where the request came from

Ward councillors presented the petition to Full Council in July 2022. It carried 29 signatures. It said residents found it “harder and harder to park on our street” and that “too many commuters” were parking there at all times of day, “often causing dangerous access problems”.

The council widened the consultation to the neighbouring streets so that any commuter parking would not simply move round the corner.

The Pottery Lane verges

Since the petition, the council has also had complaints about cars parking on and damaging the grass verges on Pottery Lane. So the questionnaire offered a second option for that street: 22 marked parking bays on the road to stop verge parking.

Across the whole area, 43 replies backed the bays and 22 did not. On Pottery Lane itself, 12 were for and 16 against. The report does not recommend the bays either: its only recommended option is no further action.

What people asked for instead

Residents were also asked what else they would like on their streets. The returns record 19 votes for street trees, 19 for benches, 12 for cycle parking and 5 for car club spaces. Officers say these will be passed to the teams concerned “so that they can be acted on when opportunity arises”.

Written comments split 19 in favour and 15 against. People against the scheme raised the cost of permits and asked for the grass verges to be removed for extra parking. Some in favour raised the speed of traffic, and the report notes that fewer parked cars could make speeding worse.

What it means for you

The decision can still be called in by councillors until 4pm on Tuesday 24 November (decision sheet). If it is not, it stands.

If the scheme were ever brought in, households would pay for permits at the council’s standard ResPark rates, which start at £115 a year for a first standard permit. The current York resident permit prices rise steeply for a second and third car. The report itself warns the cost would hit hard here, because few homes on these streets have off-street parking.

With the area off the waiting list, residents who still want permit parking would have to ask again from the start.