A non-verbal autistic boy's teachers were not trained in Makaton as his EHC plan required, for more than a year. The Ombudsman found City of York Council at fault.

City of York Council failed to give a non-verbal autistic boy the communication support set out in his Education, Health and Care (EHC) plan, the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman has found. His plan said every member of teaching staff in his classroom must be trained in Makaton to level three or four. For most of two school years, they were not.

The Ombudsman published the finding as a formal report, dated 15 October 2026 (LGSCO report 25 005 046). That means councillors must consider it at a meeting and tell the Ombudsman within three months what they are doing about it. The council has accepted the recommendations.

The report does not name the boy, his mother or his school, and neither do we.

What Makaton is, and why it mattered

Makaton uses signs, symbols and speech so that people who cannot rely on speech can communicate. It has four levels. Levels three and four cover more advanced vocabulary and how to adapt signing to one person.

The boy does not use spoken language. The report says he communicates through gestures, Makaton and objects. “For him, Makaton is not additional support, but part of the way he communicates,” the Ombudsman wrote.

What went wrong

The council issued the boy’s EHC plan in late September 2023, after a tribunal order. The report sets out what followed:

  • February and March 2024: a speech and language therapist raised concerns that staff were not using Makaton, and his mother saw the same.
  • May 2024: the therapist found classroom staff did not have suitable training. His mother complained to the council, which said the school would arrange training.
  • September 2024: the boy started his second school year with no member of teaching staff trained to level three or above, the Ombudsman found.
  • November 2024: the council told her the class teacher now held level three. After she sent a formal pre-action letter, the council accepted that was wrong: the teacher was trained only to levels one and two. It admitted it had breached its duty.
  • January 2025: the class teacher reached level three, four months into the school year.
  • July 2025: the council gave its first formal response to the complaint, more than a year after it was made.
  • September 2025: all his teaching staff were trained to the right level, at the start of his third year.

The council blamed staff absences and cancelled training courses. The Ombudsman said that “does not excuse the delay” and that the council should have looked for other trainers “rather than allowing the matter to drift”.

The council also argued the impact was limited, because staff were trained in other communication approaches. The Ombudsman rejected that. Its report says staff trained in those approaches but not in Makaton “could not communicate with Y in the way his EHC Plan required”.

Asked to explain what it was failing to provide

The report is critical of how the council handled the family. When his mother chased in July and September 2024, the council asked her which parts of the plan it was still failing to deliver.

“The Council should have known the answer to those questions,” the Ombudsman said. Asking her “reflects the Council’s continuing failure to oversee its own statutory duties.”

The money, and what happens next

The council had already paid the family £9,000 for the missed support from September 2023 to July 2025. The Ombudsman worked out the part of that covering March 2024 to July 2025, the period it investigated, at £6,450. Using its own guidance it valued that period at £8,025, so it has recommended a further payment.

The council has agreed to:

  • apologise to the boy’s mother and pay a further £1,575 within one month of the report
  • review its procedures within three months, so it checks the support in an EHC plan is in place from the start of a new or changed plan
  • draw up an action plan within three months on cutting delays in Makaton training and commissioning more trainers

The Ombudsman will share the decision with Ofsted.

Updated 12 November: the council says it has apologised to the boy’s mother and paid the further £1,575. A report to the People Scrutiny Committee on Wednesday 18 November says it has held two meetings on the action plan and will finish the actions within the three months. It says the fault happened when the SEND team was short of staff and leaders, and that the service now has a head of service and more caseworkers and plan writers. The council says it challenged the accuracy of the draft report, but accepted the findings overall (People Scrutiny report, 18 November 2026).

What it means for you

  • If your child has an EHC plan: the duty to deliver the support in section F sits with the council, even when a school provides it. The report says the courts have called that duty “non-delegable”.
  • What a council should check: the Ombudsman expects councils to confirm the support is in place when a plan is issued or changed, check it at least once a year at the annual review, and act quickly when a parent raises a concern.
  • If it is missing: complain to the council first. If that does not resolve it, you can complain to the Ombudsman, normally within 12 months of becoming aware of the problem. In this case the Ombudsman accepted a later complaint because the council’s own delay caused it.
  • Watch for the council meeting: councillors must consider the report formally. We will report what they say when it appears on an agenda.

Sources